I am – Hercules!!
Another “Doctor Who” special just hit the BBC!!
“Doctor Dan” says:
DOCTOR WHO: The Waters Of Mars
[SPOILERS] It's the beginning of the end for this incarnation of Doctor Who, as the final three episodes spearheaded by Russell T. Davies and starring David Tennant are unwrapped for winter. "The Waters Of Mars" was a fairly rudimentary episode, bolstered by some excellent villains and a final act that squeezed every last drop from the moral quandary The Doctor (Tennant) found himself caught in...
Arriving on Mars circa 2059, The Doctor is excited to see evidence of human colonisation, but upon entering "Bowie Base One" he suddenly realizes that he's stumbled into a terrible event "fixed in time" that he's forbidden to alter. Unfortunately, the inhabitants of the base, led by Adelaide Brooke (Lindsay Duncan), are infamous victims of an unexplained explosion that took their lives but helped shape the future of mankind -- primarily by inspiring Adelaide's granddaughter to become the first person to travel faster-than-light.
As it usual for The Doctor, his arrival coincided with the outbreak of an alien virus that has infected the water supply and started turning the crew into soaking wet zombies with mouths like cracked mosaic tiles, who are able to project water from their mouths and arms to infect anyone who comes into contact with the slightest drop.
The first half of "The Waters Of Mars" was breezy, formulaic stuff for Doctor Who, reminding us of various other episodes in the show's recent history – most obviously "The Impossible Planet". There was another melange of actors doing unconvincing accents, a "funny robot" called Gadget as a concession to the kids, countless foot pursuits up corridors, encounters with the enemy behind portholes, and more evidence of Russell T. Davies' fascination with segways (as the aforementioned robot is turned into a makeshift version thanks to the multipurpose sonic screwdriver.)
But, it was still a very engaging first half, primarily because "The Flood" enemy were genuinely creepy and horrifying creations. A few sequences of people quivering as they were enveloped in water were very effectively shot and unnerving for a show skewed towards families with young kids. But the real success behind "The Waters Of Mars" came in the second half, when The Doctor decided to leave everyone behind to meet their tragedy and ensure the timeline is maintained... only to have second thoughts when it dawns on him that, as the last of the governing Time Lords, it's really up to him how things pan out.
Interestingly, this was the first time I can remember when it felt wrong to see The Doctor trying valiantly to save the day (despite the heroic poses the camera afforded him when he returned), and there were some beautifully played moments in the denouement when The Doctor suspected he'd gone too far in altering time and saving everyone's lives. The Doctor now thinks of himself as a "winner" of the infamous Time War, not a "survivor", and surely has too much power at his disposal if he's refusing to obey established laws of time. After all, even a Dalek (seen in a flashback to "The Stolen Earth") knew it was in everyone's best interest to let Adelaide live as a young girl. You have to take a good hard look at yourself if the Daleks have the moral high ground, don't you?
Overall, "The Waters Of Mars" was fast and furious fun, but it wasn't until the final twenty minutes that it really started to give us something new and interesting to chew on. Everything before was perfectly entertaining stuff, but too reminiscent of past glories. It's perhaps a wise move of Russell T. Davies to move on from the show now, if stories are starting to remind you of other episodes, only with different people being imperilled by villains with different quirks.
Rating: 4/5
The Good
David Tennant, of course. It almost goes without saying. He's always a joy to watch on-screen, but he proved to be absolutely riveting in the dramatic moments that took over the second half. His speech to Adelaide about her death being a necessity for the greater good of mankind was particularly excellent, as was the denouement when we saw a darker side of The Doctor's character come through.
Lindsay Duncan. She wasn't really involved in a story that could showcase her acting that well, but her quieter moments towards the end were nicely handled and Adelaide's final scene with The Doctor was very touching.
The Flood. Some excellent make-up design and performances, ensuring these villains stand a good chance of giving a few young kids some nightmares. Bath time's certainly going to be fun for many families this week.
The special effects. Sure, the odd greenscreen was noticeable, but this was generally a high benchmark for Doctor Who. The Mars base and the climactic explosion were convincing, and the set design and location shooting worked very well to bring Mars to life on a BBC budget. I'm sure it's helped that BBC Wales have had much longer to fine-tune things with these intermittent specials in 2009.
The last act was particularly great -- big emotions, a few surprises, a fascinating look at The Doctor facing his own demons and fears of mortality. And I'm sure there are people who will be more excited about the preview for "The End Of Time" than anything in this episode itself.
The Bad
The annoying robot Gadget (with its incessant "gadget, gadget!" catchphrase) was incredibly irritating, and having it be instrumental in saving the day was obvious from the moment it appeared.
The first 30-minutes weren't "bad", but the story was so similarly constructed to previous episodes of nu-Who, that it was certainly tarnished by a mild sense of déjà vu.
The way The Doctor "flashed" on memories of reading obituaries/news reports about the crew felt like silly and lazy writing. You could have cut them out and just let David Tennant's expressions tell you all you needed to know.
Why didn't the infected woman being detained escape much earlier, if it was so easy?
The Geeky
This episode was dedicated to the 1970s-era producer Barry Letts, who died a month ago.
Actor Chook Sibtain previously played Mark Grantham in The Sarah Jane Adventures' episode "Warriors Of Kudlak"
Bowie Base One is an allusion to singer-songwriter David Bowie, who had a famous hit 1973 single Life On Mars.
The Doctor is seen wearing a modified version of the spacesuit from The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit.
The last time The Doctor was on Mars was for 1975's The Pyramids Of Mars.
Reference is made to The Ice Warriors, a Martian species who appeared in "The Ice Warriros", "The Seeds Of Death", "The Curse Of Peladon" and "The Monster Of Peladon".
The Doctor likened this temporal situation to the one he encountered at Pompeii, in the episode "The Fires Of Pompeii"
The final scene included the sound of a cloister bell, which has been used since 1980's "Logpolis" to signal a time of great catastrophe of impending danger on the show. The sound has also been used in "Castrovalva", "Resurrection Of The Daleks", "The Sound Of Drums" and "Turn Left"
Doctor Dan
“JADSTERSDAD” says:
I've attempted reviews of quite a few Tennant Whos. None has been more difficult than this. As usual, attemptedly spoiler-free. Exposition I'll leave to others.
This episode was co-written by Davies and Phil Ford, who did such a good job on many of Gerry Anderson's revived Captain Scarlet episodes (sadly underrated). How much that accounts for my reaction I don't know.
For me, this episode crystallised all that is good and bad about new Who. All that is best and worst. I had such mixed feelings throughout that I felt like I was on a kind of rollercoaster. There are many, many 'quiet' moments of dialogue between characters and David Tennant himself has an unusual amount of scenes where he is literally.... quiet. Observing. Thinking. These work well. Also his exchanges with guest star Lindsay Duncan ring very true. Chiefly because she is a great actress and great in this role. But the writer (?) must take credit also.
Then, though, there are..... the gratuitous gay reference. Now I've never minded these or commented on them before. But here, in a sea of such gravitas, it really stands out. If it came organically, then fine. This is the most clumsy shoe-horn ever. Next we have the running. Lots of scenes of running. And the pounding soundtrack. The first of these is a complete red herring and totally unnecessary. There's no real urgency. I think two characters were just summoned back to control or something. See, I can't even remember. But the music blares... the actors run....etc. Later, David Tennant gets to blare himself in familiar Tennant-Doc style. And run. God, even an annoying robot runs (in a badly misjudged scene). The robot is another generally bad thing, I think. Standing out like a sore metal thumb amidst the heavy atmosphere.
Lets get to the monsters. I think most people have seen the trailers. Their makeup is fine and pretty unpleasant. The idea of water being so threatening is a good one and does play out well. As the Doctor says.. water is 'persistent'. But when it shoots out of the monster's sleeve, well that's clumsily done and spoils the carefully crafted illusion. That's my overriding impression here. Quality, quality work (special effects, set design, acting, writing etc.) let down by silly or cut-price moments.
But I'm carping. The spine of the show, which is a meditation on time and interference on time-lines, takes a surprising turn. The finale is genuinely moving and we get to see a side of this Doctor we haven't seen before. Perhaps one we haven't seen in any Doctor before. And it's very compelling. This show's place in the final three episodes of Tennant's Doctor career is what makes it special. By the end, you just want to damn well see the other two! Although the return (inevitably) of past characters will divide people. Donna (my head droops); The Master (thank god); Bernard Cribbins (whoopee!). The set up here is great for going into the next and final story. I just hope they don't fluff it like they did the final part of series three.
Oh.. and there are nice throwaway references to things that will delight series devotees.
Still a difficult call, but I'd give this one 8/10 (which is fine if I get my 9/10 and 10/10 for the next two, in that order).
A final, final thought. I found myself wondering that, after JJ's Star Trek, the way they have reinvented Who now feels slightly wanting. Maybe that's just me. I'm not biased, though. I grew up loving Trek and Who equally.
Like pretty much everyone else, I'm now very eager for the cast and crew change next year. But let's enjoy this - guilty pleasures and all - while we can. We don't know what's in the future........
“Amiga Power” says:
Having just watched the waters of Mars on a cold Rainy Sunday night in Britain I have to say I feel wiped out. Awash with emotion and riding a wave of excitement. (yes, I'll stop, sorry)
The cast is Excellent headed up by Lindsay Duncan playing Adelaide who, as far as I can tell, is Ripley's Mum. The monsters are typically scary and at some points a little disturbing. The plot runs along nicely without giving you too long to pick it apart before things start going pear shaped.
The story opens With the Doctor visiting Mars unaware of the significant event about to occur. The key point of the story is that this is one of those “Fixed points in time” you know the Doctor's mentioned those before, like those tricky deadlock seals that were invented to stop the Doctor being too powerful. Any who the event cannot be changed and the Doctor must not interfere hmm I wonder what he is thinking about doing. The plot is well constructed and feels like a classic story with standard Doctor who moments of capture, escape, rescue. Like every good story this creates the conflict and by far the best moments of tension in the episode are played out between the Doctor and Adelaide. By the end of the episode you'll have been impressed by the visuals believe you're on Mars, been embarrassed by the robot, wondered when the Doctor was going to turn around.
Deciding who lives and who dies has often been a staple of Doctor who wondering who will be alive at the end of the episode is a great game to play. Although this episode get gradually darker and by the end you'll be surprised if anyone is left standing.
Tennant gets some more moments to push his acting (shouting) to the limit, the second twist of the episode (which you can just see coming) is darker than I thought the show would ever go. I won't spoil it but I really don't think the ending is appropriate for what many think of as a children's show. And quite the reason for it I'm not convinced of.
The good – Setting and effects make this special look like a proper blockbuster and why not.
- New improved darker doctor goes where no doctor has been before.
Excellent monsters that scared the water out of me
The bad – The robot – Doctor who doesn't have a great record on robots and really they haven't improved Imagine Wall – E built out of Lego with a flat battery. K9's starting to look quite hi tech.
- the whole plot hinges on the idea that you can't change time.... oh but guess what happens
Many of the problems with Current Doctor who are here nonsensical plot, pointless running down corridors, meaningless deaths. Coupled with the good bits great actors, acting, great effects and classic sci fi plots. We will have to see which of these elements win out in the final airing before Mr Tennant kicks the bucket.
(Oh should that last bit have been a spoiler)
“The Geekest Link” says:
It’s the beginning of the end for the Doctor in this special episode of arrogance and regret on the red planet. Waters of Mars lays down the gauntlet for what’s to come and it’s clear the writers are intent on making David Tennant’s exit from the show as emotive as possible.
While the actual meat of the episode was somewhat lacklustre, with 28 Days Later-esque zombies running about spewing water from their mouths, it’s the unexpected twists and turns of the latter half that knocks this episode out of the ball park.
The Doctor arrives on Mars to find a group of human researchers have set up a base atop a glacier. There, something alien has worked its way into the water supply and is slowly taking over the crew – transforming them into something... terrible.
As soon as the Doctor realises where he is, and that the happenings on Mars must occur if Earth is going to take to the stars, he is understandably anxious to leave the colony to its fate. This is a fixed moment in history, something the Doctor knows he cannot change. Everyone must die if the deaths are to inspire Captain Adelaide’s ( Lindsay Duncan) grandchildren to play a major part in the development of Earth’s interstellar travel.
The strength of this episode is not in the weak storyline, but in the Doctor himself. Impotent to save the colony, he comes to a realization: the Time Lords are gone and there is no one left to govern the Laws of Time. He is alone and Time is his alone to shape.
With no one to stop him, the Doctor returns to the colony to rescue the final three members of the crew. He is defiant that even Time cannot hinder him in his quest to change a fixed moment in history, and it’s his anger and passion and energy that makes this episode so very special.
But there’s an even bigger twist to come, when the Doctor, filled with all the arrogance and knowledge of the universe, declares himself the Time Lord Victorious; it’s a breath-taking moment as you realise the Doctor can do anything. Unfettered by his people, he is free to do as he sees fit, to rearrange history with impunity. He is practically a god.
Yet it doesn’t last. The final unexpected twist brings the Doctor crashing to his senses when he realises that his death is imminent. But he isn’t going to go out without a fight. The end is coming...
Overall, Waters of Mars was far from the ‘scariest episode’ that was so freely bandied about by the BBC. But what this episode does show the Doctor (and Tenant) in all his glory and majesty. It shows his remorse, his regret, his arrogance and, for the first time, his genuine fear of death. It reveals just how great an actor David Tenant is and how wonderful his portrayal of the Doctor has been.
With just two episodes to go, this glorious insight into the Time Lord psyche will only make the inevitable ending that much more bitter-sweet.
“Gabba UK” says:
Hi Herc,
Well, I pulled myself away from Modern Warfare 2 long enough to watch The Waters Of Mars and before I settle down to watch the return of Top Gear I thought I'd spin you a couple of lines about it.
November 21st 2059.
The colonist's of the first base on Mars are about to receive a visiter. But he shouldn't be there. It's a fixed point in time, It can't be altered and as we all know, he can't leave well alone if humans are in danger.
This is of course, the penultimate outing for Tennet as the good Doctor and as a result it has the feel of a set-up story for the big Christmas special. That in no way detracted from the fact that its was a cracking bit of Sunday night entertainment. RTD co-wrote it so the usual problems crop up but his usual excess's seemed to have reigned in by the other writer, Phil Ford.
This episode brings a whole new meaning to the phrase 'something in the water'. Something that was pretty frightening actually. An infection leads to one of the colonists getting chapped lips and the kind of sweat problem that even the best antiperspirant is going to have problems coping with.
The problem for The Doctor is that all the colonist's die, they are meant to die and it's important to the future of the human race that Captain Adelaide Brook dies with them. This is not really a spoiler as its apparent to the viewer that this is the case within a couple of minutes. This story is all about the Doctor coming to terms with the fact that he is not just the last of the Timelords, he IS a Timelord and he has been forgetting that recently. There is nothing he can't do, he controls time and the Universe had better start getting used to it.
This gets us back to what Donna told him that he needs someone with him, to keep him in check and stop him doing just that and when he starts to rail against time itself shout to all that he's in charge, he begins to sound like he's channeling The Master.......
Whats good? Well, the production, save for one tragic mis-step (those who've seen it will know that I'm talking about) is top notch. They went all out on this one. The special effects of the Mars base are pretty special to be honest, with a very convincing CGI explosion. Lyndsey Duncan, as always, gives a great performance as the doomed Captain Brook. The make-up was good and there were a few good lines of dialogue, "Water is patient, water always wins."
Whats bad? The tragic mis-step I mentioned earlier, which is really so tragic I don't want to mention it.
The teaser at the end tells us Christmas 2009, The End Of Time
Flashes of The Docter Running, Bernard Cribbins (Yeaaaaahhh), Catherine Tate (Noooooo), the Ood saying they have bad dreams, 'He will knock four times', a voice warning us of a darkness and the end of time (sounding a lot like Brian Cox), "They call me... The Master." "I'm going to die...."
Can't Wait.
“The Handsome 12th Doctor” says:
Eek, that was a bit grim wasn't it. In the best possible way that is.
As we head towards Ten's end things are turning darker. This was scary-Who at its coolest. I think the BBC missed a trick by not sticking this episode on at Halloween.
From the very outset it was like a sci-fi zombie tale. You may argue that *real* zombies can't run like that. And you may be right. But what I mean is it played out under the rules of a zombie film.
There was the infected. And if you're attacked by one then you became one of them, and then you have the urge to go attack the other 'living' folk. And it built up to the scenario where a group of survivors got trapped by the aliens/zombies.
I'd say this was a nicely scary set-up for the 7pm family slot. Pushed to the limit by the extra creepy make-up on the aliens/zombies.
Then came the water feature. This infection came out of the water(s of Mars). If you got just one drop of it on you then you became infected. And these were extremely leaky zombies. Water spurting out all over the place.
I liked how the director used a good mix of CGI and practical techniques for this. The choice each time seemed the right one.
A story such as this is always helped by having first-rate actors to keep it grounded. One name jumps out tonight. Lindsay Servilia of the Duncan.
Since coming back this show has attracted a shiny smorgasbord of talent, and I'd now place Lindsay Duncan at the head of the list. She gave a classy authoritative performance that benefited the action well. While David Tennant reigned himself in (mostly). I think he's much better when he's like this, rather than that "Alons-y" buggering about foppishly style he's been known to do. And I was even more impressed by the twist in his attitude when the Doc decided what being last of the Timelords meant. That was some quite ballsy writing at the end from RTD.
Praise also goes to the production crew for the design of Bowie Base. Yes, it really was called that. But that's perfectly credible. Scientists in real life do have a corny sense of humour.
So yeah, the sets looked great. They made me think of a modernized take on 'Silent Running'. They even had a funny robot.Something that will likely be the common target of hate here. Those who didn't like the flying bus the last time are probably not going to be too keen on a roadrunner robot.
Me? I liked the robot. I didn't like the altered theme tune though. They keep messing about with it, and it keeps getting worse each time. Another thing I didn't care for was the Star Trek Russian bloke. In fact the whole Trek league of nations thing. It's been done so often it's beyond a cliche now.
But those are little negatives I can easily ignore. Because the rest was all good to me. Capped off by a trailer that made me wish it was Christmas now.
“SPUD MCSPUD” says:
Hey Herc,
Here's a review of tonight's DR WHO - THE WATERS OF MARS, which is Tennant's second-to-last episode as The Doctor. If you use this, call me SPUD MCSPUD...
So - RTD's only got two episodes left to dispatch Tennant's Doctor with after this episode, so he's going to need lots of foreshadowing, and a sense of impending doom. He's teased us with glimpses of a claustrophobic, frightening siege drama set in the first Earth colony on Mars. Does he pull it off?
Hmm. YES and NO.
The plot overview: It's Nov 21st 2059, and the first Earth colony on Mars has been established for a third of its way through a planned five-year mission. The Doctor, travelling sans companion, is just passing through, and lands on Mars. He decides to go and have a look at the colony (which looks great by the way) and ends up meeting the Martian pioneers... who are supposed to have something very bad happen to them. A lot is made out of the idea of the Doctor being in the wrong place at the wrong time - apparently this situation is one of those fixed points in time he cannot change, no matter what. He should just leave.
Does he just leave? HELL no!
As is plain from the trailer, the colonists find themselves getting possessed, one by one, by water-based life-forms that exist only to possess others, and to get to Earth. Where there is A LOT of water. Which apparently they need to survive. What ensues is an hour of running (there's a nice joke about "Why didn't you bring bikes?" "A pound in weight costs three tonnes of fuel." "Still, though... no bikes?!"), people turning round quickly and snarling as they turn into H2O zombies, and every possible Carpenter rip off that RTD and writing partner Phil Ford could ram in there. Spurting jets of water possessing humans? That's PRINCE OF DARKNESS. Siege horror set in a claustrophobic environment it's near impossible to escape? That'd be THE THING, then. Lots of info relayed through comm screens and radios? The Snake Plissken movies (okay, I'm belabouring the point). But it does feel more a Carpenter script than a RTD one.
How about how it feels as a DR WHO episode? Well, this is the problem: it DOESN'T. It's the only Who episode I can think of where the Doctor literally does nothing to change the situation until the very, very end - and even then, it REALLY doesn't go well. There's an innocuous reference to "he will knock four times" - well, the spoilers are all over the net as to who THAT means and why - and it isn't paid off. There's much pomp and bluster from the Doctor as to who he is and what his "last of the Time Lords" status should mean, and gives us an out-of-character scene where the Doctor gets to be insufferably arrogant and smug - which will presumably lead to his doom in the last two episodes. The whole tone to begin with is of existential despair, of an oncoming apocalypse that the characters just have to come to terms with, not to change or escape from. In short, it sounds like RTD took his own script from TORCHWOOD - CHILDREN OF EARTH or THE SECOND COMING, tried to clean it up for family consumption, and and just shoehorned the Doctor in there. It feels like an end-of-the-world adventure by way of Nigel Kneale / John Carpenter / late-night RTD, but turned into a DR WHO adventure.
Is it good, though? For RTD's stuff, YES - it's frightening where it should be, has a nice air of hopelessness to it, the background details of the colonists and what their mission means for the spacefaring future of humankind is well done, beautifully put across in some very economical scenes, well written and tight as a drum. For others, NO - I'd have loved to see Paul Cornell, Stephen Moffat or even Gareth Roberts give this a go. It's a bit shitty having the Doctor observe for 50 out of 55 minutes, then decide to alter the unalterable outcome out of some misplaced arrogance that comes out of nowhere, simply because the script demands it. Why bother with the whole episode, if the Doctor does virtually nothing? It just seems pointless. The Doctor needed to be much more pro-active. And there's a vision at the end that makes no sense whatsoever. Yes, I know it's foreshadowed by an early episode in Season 4, but why would the Doctor see what he sees? Absolutely stupid moment...
All in all? Undemanding, nice sense of menace and foreboding, but almost no involvement from the Doctor - which renders the whole thing a bit unnecessary. Tennant is better than he's been in a while, but Lindsay Duncan walks away with the acting plaudits here. She's great in a very sketchy role, and brings more heart than this material deserves.
The less said about the concluding two-parter to Tennant's reign, the better. Suffice to say, the Flash Gordon rip-off scene at the end of LAST OF THE TIME LORDS is paying off in the finale. I'm breaking out the RTD BINGO CARD to see if I can finally fill it in the last Tennant episodes:

“DrSamBeckett” says:
Well. We all know this is the third last outing for David Tennant’s brilliant tenth Doctor, and this episode is probably the least child friendly episode ever made. And while that is by no means a bad thing for us adults watching, but young children might want to give this one a miss.
Story wise, this is deliberately basic. We never find out the precise nature of the watery menace that terrify the Doctor and the small group of humans exploring Mars from Bowie Base. There are a few nice notions back to the old series, the Ice Warriors are mentioned more than once. The group of humans are the usual collection of mixed races that the ever politically correct Doctor Who likes to offer. And to be honest, at no real point do we care about any of them, mainly because there is no time for real character development, with the notable exception of Adelade Brooke, the base’s brash captain.
She is instantly distrustful of the Doctor, as they always are, but she soon realises he isn’t going to harm them. We learn from the Doctor, that history records the base was destroyed, and all he wants to do is leave, because this is a fixed point in time that even he cannot alter. For Adelade’s granddaughter is a pioneer of light speed space travel, spurred on by her grandmother’s death on Mars. The Doctor knows all this from the beginning, he knows these people are destined to die and even he can’t change that. It is a fixed point in time.
However....
The Doctor does something very naughty, and he saves three of the crew, including Adelade. To this act, the consequences will be undeniably severe.
There is some action in this episode, and some great special effects.
All through this episode, we are privy to a mass sense of foreboding, the Doctor is going to die and he knows it. And after his actions at the episodes conclusion, his scary speech to Adelade, we begin to see a different person in the Doctor. This is a worrying character development, I saw less of the Doctor there, and more of The Master. The look in David Tennant’s eyes is one of raw power, we always were aware of the power of a time lord, but now we see that in an intimidating way. Even the Doctor realises he has gone too far.
But it is way too late for that, the damage is done. Just see the trailer at the end.
The End Of Time, is coming.
“Joedini” says:
Thought i would weigh in with my thoughts on Waters Of Mars, the latest Doctor Who special.
I went into this with my fingers crossed after being beyond disappointed with Planet Of The Dead, and luckily this more than made up for that.
I'm not the hugest fan of episodes penned by Russel T Davies but i'm starting to warm to him after this and Children Of Earth. With WOM he has knocked one out the park, just brilliant. If I come out of an episode and my only complaint is the over use of internet clippings (which was smacking the audience in the face with an already easy enough to grasp concept) then I know I've watched a winner.
This is a very diffrent Doctor Who. Sure it starts with an air of familiarity, base in toruble, group of people in danger, long corridor chases, all akin to tales such as '42' and 'The Impossible Planet' but around the halfway mark the story changes. The tone gets dark, very dark. RTD writes a number of emotional scenes that are written and played pitch perfect and the panic that is shown on screen tanslates well.
We also see a different doctor, a darker arrogant Doctor, something far removed froma way we have seen the character before, it's a joy to watch as much as it is unsettling.
This maybe the first Who story that might not be suitable for children, sure there has been scares before; 'Blink' terrifies me even on a rewatch. But this is different. A scene at the end depicts something that is very uncommon in the BBC's early schedule. But all of this only helps to boost the story and make it possibly one of the best New Who's we have seen.
We also did get a trailer for 'The End Of Time' at the end which makes the wait even more unbearable.
Roll on Christmas, roll on New year. David Tennant will be sorely missed but if this episode is any indication, he really is going out with a bang.
“Palimpsest” says:
Hi Herc
A quick heads-up on the second of 2009's four episodes of WHO, which has just premiered in the UK.
It's 2059 and a companion-less Doctor lands on Mars, where the first Earth manned mission has been on the Martian surface for 17 months. The Doctor pops in to say hello, largely to meet space legend and pioneer Adelaide Brooke (a guesting Lindsay Duncan). However, he's turned up on exactly the wrong day...
Cue plenty of running down corridors, jokes about running down corridors, a comedy robot, some very effective practical make-up courtesy of Neill Gorton's crew, and some less-convincing CG thanks to The Mill.
However, as is usual with WHO, spectacle comes a distant second to fascinating moral quandaries, as The Doctor is tempted to step way over the rules the Time Lords set in place...
Nods to at least three John Carpenter movies (PRINCE OF DARKNESS, THE THING and GHOSTS OF MARS) will please/infuriate the geeks, but the best thing about the episode is the darker tone throughout, the decent scares, and The Doctor's growing realisation that his time may be up.
The now-traditional teaser trailer for the nest episode promises the return of The Master (John Simm in nifty cowl and bleach white cropped hair). That ep, THE END OF TIME should premiere in the UK on Christmas Day, with one more to follow, probably screening on Jan 1st 2010.

Follow Herc on Twitter!!

$10 SINGLE-DISC!!
Star Trek (2009)
Star Trek (2009): Two-Disc
Star Trek (2009) (Blu-ray)
Star Trek Limited Edition Replica Gift Set

Play Them On A $127.25 Blu-ray Player!!

Shipping Now!!
$17.50 For 1,088 Pages
From The King, Baby!!
The Good David Tennant, of course. It almost goes without saying. He's always a joy to watch on-screen, but he proved to be absolutely riveting in the dramatic moments that took over the second half. His speech to Adelaide about her death being a necessity for the greater good of mankind was particularly excellent, as was the denouement when we saw a darker side of The Doctor's character come through. Lindsay Duncan. She wasn't really involved in a story that could showcase her acting that well, but her quieter moments towards the end were nicely handled and Adelaide's final scene with The Doctor was very touching. The Flood. Some excellent make-up design and performances, ensuring these villains stand a good chance of giving a few young kids some nightmares. Bath time's certainly going to be fun for many families this week. The special effects. Sure, the odd greenscreen was noticeable, but this was generally a high benchmark for Doctor Who. The Mars base and the climactic explosion were convincing, and the set design and location shooting worked very well to bring Mars to life on a BBC budget. I'm sure it's helped that BBC Wales have had much longer to fine-tune things with these intermittent specials in 2009. The last act was particularly great -- big emotions, a few surprises, a fascinating look at The Doctor facing his own demons and fears of mortality. And I'm sure there are people who will be more excited about the preview for "The End Of Time" than anything in this episode itself.
The Bad The annoying robot Gadget (with its incessant "gadget, gadget!" catchphrase) was incredibly irritating, and having it be instrumental in saving the day was obvious from the moment it appeared. The first 30-minutes weren't "bad", but the story was so similarly constructed to previous episodes of nu-Who, that it was certainly tarnished by a mild sense of déjà vu. The way The Doctor "flashed" on memories of reading obituaries/news reports about the crew felt like silly and lazy writing. You could have cut them out and just let David Tennant's expressions tell you all you needed to know. Why didn't the infected woman being detained escape much earlier, if it was so easy?
The Geeky This episode was dedicated to the 1970s-era producer Barry Letts, who died a month ago. Actor Chook Sibtain previously played Mark Grantham in The Sarah Jane Adventures' episode "Warriors Of Kudlak" Bowie Base One is an allusion to singer-songwriter David Bowie, who had a famous hit 1973 single Life On Mars. The Doctor is seen wearing a modified version of the spacesuit from The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit. The last time The Doctor was on Mars was for 1975's The Pyramids Of Mars. Reference is made to The Ice Warriors, a Martian species who appeared in "The Ice Warriros", "The Seeds Of Death", "The Curse Of Peladon" and "The Monster Of Peladon". The Doctor likened this temporal situation to the one he encountered at Pompeii, in the episode "The Fires Of Pompeii" The final scene included the sound of a cloister bell, which has been used since 1980's "Logpolis" to signal a time of great catastrophe of impending danger on the show. The sound has also been used in "Castrovalva", "Resurrection Of The Daleks", "The Sound Of Drums" and "Turn Left" Doctor Dan





