Here's just a tidbit... Out of the two suggestions, I'd prefer Elijah, simply because the part kinda calls for someone that can act the ENTIRE range... from top to bottom. From loving to killing, and I think it'd be fascinating to see Elijah do that... The role would go a long ways towards 'growing' him up on screen.
I know you are looking forward to the production of the new movie Patriot. I read in a soap opera magazine ( Soaps In Depth) that Jonathan Jackson and Elijah Woods are two of the actors being considered to play opposite Mel Gibson--as the son. Just letting you know. I am looking forward to any and all information you have regarding this movie.
Magical Melissa
